I got Penny for My Thoughts in last year’s Secret Cthanta’s exchange and have gotten to play it both on VOIP and in real life. I quite like it! Because it’s a storytelling game and plays a little different in each format, I’m really curious what a Play-By-Forum game of Penny for my Thoughts will look like, so I’m finding out by running two games of it on the RPG Geek forums.
So far I like it a lot! The extra pause you can take to think about your next memory or guiding question works a long way towards making coherent stories, I think. Though it does lose something in spontaneity.